Comment the Graphic Above
| Author | Message |
|---|---|
| snow at christmas. Crash Queen  Age: 38 Gender: Male Posts: 31690 | In this thread, what you do is state at least one good thing and one bad thing about the graphic above, and then post a graphic of yours. This is for icons, banners, wallpapers, anything. It just has to be yours, since the point is to help everyone improve their stuff through constructive criticism. It seems like a lot of stuff gets ignored in the specific threads or just doesn't get adequate criticism, so I figured this would help. Hopefully other people find this as useful as I think it will be. "/  And go. (: |
| my chemical romance. Banned  Age: 30 Gender: Female Posts: 18584 | PROS: Amazing cropping, and the colouring suits the image really well. CONS: The paper textures are overused and I'm getting tired of seeing them. . . .  |
| the whack parade. Demolition Lover  Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 19756 | Ooh, I like this thread! Pros: Amazing coloring and good text placement. Cons: Something about the texture seems a little off. Maybe it should be on the other side, because with the text there it seems a little busy. oops, that was for Sarah. Pros: I like how Gerard is placed. Overall, it's great. Cons: I feel like the empty space on the right could use more.  |
| Missing Zero Awake and Unafraid  Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 13405 | Pros: i love the colouring, very nice Cons: one i dont like her but whatever thats my opinion, but think her face should be a bit darker cos it seems too white  |
| point counterpoint. Always Born a Crime  Age: - Gender: - Posts: 5199 | Pros: The coloring is amazing. Cons: I think the text placement doesn't fit the image well. ----  |
| Missing Zero Awake and Unafraid Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 13405 | i absolutly love this one, the coloring is lovely however i think u went a bit texture happy with that texture lol Edit: To the one above! i love the coloring just amazing  con: i cant see anything wrong with it sorry XD (i was late to enter the incon comp so i might aswell post it lol)  EDIT :late |
| snow at christmas. Crash Queen Age: 38 Gender: Male Posts: 31690 | Pro: I LOVE the colors, it's so vibrant. Con: I feel like, since there are two focal points, you end up with your eye right in between them, looking at nothing.  Ehh, this thing is shit. |
| filthy hands. Shotgun Sinner  Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 8403 | Pro: It's really beautiful, it's simple and the coloring is really pretty. Con: the text could be bigger or a little darker, the words kinda fade into the background. ----  |
| the whack parade. Demolition Lover Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 19756 | Pro: Great image to icon. Cons: Seems too oversharpened, and the text is hard to see.  |
| my chemical romance. Banned Age: 30 Gender: Female Posts: 18584 | Pros: Great colouring, and the blue and pink tones really suit the image. Cons: I think a duplicated sharpened layer on low opacity would make it look a bit better. But really, I'm just saying that to have a con. It looks perfect to me.  |
| sookeh. Crash Queen  Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 32114 | Pros: i love the texture in the back ground. Cons: im not all that into the cropping of the pic of frank, its just me im not into that style. my ava:  |
| Juliet Simms Salute You in Your Grave  Age: 31 Gender: Female Posts: 2053 | I like this idea! anyway pros: the cropping is great cons: that light texture doesn't really fit with the image. it's very distracting.  |
| yelyahwilliams Tragic With a Capital T  Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 45633 | i really like it ^_^ pro - I really like the texture/effect you have used. con - can't say there's anything wrong, because i really like it. but if anything, maybe do something else with the text. (maybe could have tried making it green)  |
| asha shake. Devil's Got Your Number  Age: 35 Gender: Female Posts: 36414 | Pro: I really love the blending Con: I think the scribble/text at the top makes it look a bit busy for my liking  |
| ageha. Bulletproof Heart  Age: 30 Gender: Female Posts: 25049 | pro - the text fits really nicely. con - its hard to make out who the person is.  |
| sookeh. Crash Queen Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 32114 | pro: i like the texture and croping. con: it is a little bright and diffucult to see.  |
| the doctor. Always Born a Crime  Age: 103 Gender: Female Posts: 5519 | PROS: I like the coloring CONS: I think it would've been better without the text/I can't read the text  |
| kinney. Bulletproof Heart  Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 29482 | PROS: The cropping is very unuasual. You don't see many Icons of feet. CONS: the colouring isn't very exciting.  |
| sookeh. Crash Queen Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 32114 | |
| kinney. Bulletproof Heart Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 29482 |
Options
Go back to top
Go back to top