I Don't Love You Video !!!

Violent Pose:

I just watched the video...I thought it was absolutely amazing.
That song is beautiful and so is the video.
I loved the whole thing with them falling...that was pretty awesome, lol.

How long you had that name? Damn, now I gotta go back and find something else!

Chemical-Hamster:

Actually, I am a huge MCR fan and I have been for a very long time. That 'rude comment' is my opinon. I'm so so sorry for it being different to yours. You can imply that I'm not a 'true' fan all you like, it doesn't change MY OPINION, or 'status' as a fan. Why should I care if I'm surronded by fans who love a video? Should I lie about what I think?

By the way, I'm not the one with the problem.

NOpoetAcriminal:

i actually thought the facial expressions were perfect if they were going to go for an over-the-top theatric feel.

did anyone else notice gerard's sweet ass dance moves? its just after frank's guitar smashes through glass i think (don't quote me on it)

NOpoetAcriminal:

does anyone else think Frank grew his hair out so he could head-bang better? It's all swooshy now. i think i like... except his hair looks sorta like mine and my grandma already mistakes pics of me and frank (weird, i know).

Burn all the Empires:

Hey guys,
How about we stop having a go at each other and discuss the video sensibly and with good reasons to back up your POV. We are all intitled to our opinions, so we should be able to respect each others and not dismiss them straight away. Can we also please cut out the swearing, there isn't really any need for it, maybe express your opinions using constructive language.

Ok, now I've babbled on I'll start with a constructive opinion!

I think this video is remarkable. It captures the essence of what the song is about. It may seem to be an obvious choice to use male and female characters but the way it's portrayed as them being almost opposites (using contrast of colour and tone) with the initial attraction and then the falling apart of the realtionship. The almost touching, but not quite, really makes you feel the pain of loving someone so deeply but then realising it can't go on or that those feelings are not the same anymore (and that really is painful - believe me). Especially the when they explode and crash to the ground at the end, like the final collapse into despair, and I would like to think this is the 'rock bottom' of both their lives before they are both reborn - apart.
The use of the band in video is not over-done, but subtle and beautifully filmed and performed. Gerards performance to the camera is incredible, I have never seen anything like it, such depth and honesty in his eyes, it's like he's actually looking and talking straight to you from his soul, and it is captured perfectly.
As for being Emo, to me Emo is just a label that people who don't understand certain types of music use to describe it when they want to put a label on something or box it in to be put on a certain shelf. MCR break these boundaries, noone knows where to put them, because they are just them, not just rock, punk rock, metal, emo, pop etc...... they don't sound like anyone else.
The use of black and white is perfect for the tone of the video and the meaning of the song, it's almost resembling the simplicity of the emotions of the ending of a love, it's over, that's it.
As for comparison with other videos, there isn't really any other that I can initially think of that are similar. I'm sure there probably is just because of the Black and White, and the lovers, but this fits the song, it's appropriate and meaningful, unlike a lot of other artisits who don't come up with the ideas themselves, they just let directors give them treatments about their interpretation of the song and pick the one they like the most, whereas MCR are one of the few bands who always have control.

Well there you go, I'd love to hear other peoples opinions (in a non-offensive, constructive manner.).