Anarchy
| Author | Message |
|---|---|
| Jordyn Fabulous Killjoy  Age: 32 Gender: Female Posts: 160 | |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay  Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | What are your reasons? Why is it we're all assuming that without rules the human race would become an irresponsible, uneducated bunch of murderers? |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | assiralc talc: Allow me to answer your second question first If people are given the choice to work or not work,theres a good chance they wont work,if people are given the chance the go to school or not go to school,theres a good chance they wont go to school. now lets say someone in anarchy land wants to work and opens a store if a man robs a store in anarchy land,because he fears no punishment and the store owner shoots him what then? |
| PunkerThanThou Thinking Happy Thoughts Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 596 | I'd say half you kids who claim to be anarchists don't even know what anarchy is. It is not total chaos. It is not total peace. It is not a cult the Sex Pistols started. I'm on the brink of following Anarchist idealogy, actually, simply because of a few revelations I've had concerning laws, regulations, and government; of course, there is anarchy in moderation- meaning, some anarchists believe in SOME form of government. Anarchists do, surprisingly have some great ideas- overlooked, but great ideas nevertheless. For those of you who approve/disapprove of anarchy and actually know what it is, I respect your ideas. |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | Austing: There would be no judicial system to punish the store owner or the man. That's just one possible scenario that could arise in an anarchist society, and one that often occurs in societies that follow current judicial system. I don't think you can say directly that anarchy leads to criminality because criminality exists in non-anarchists societies. Modern anarchism advocates the rejection of oppressive governmental systems and the creation of self-ruling forms of trade in the hope that this will reestablish standards of morality lost under capitalism. (That sounded like a load of twaddle, but it makes sense to me.) I just see that anarchy is often equated with chaos and nihilism, which makes me try to return to its idealogy. |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | assiralc talc: Thats nice,I understand that In a society with a government though,both those men would be punished Why don't you answer my question now |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | I thought I did answer your question- they would not be punished by a government. I can't really give a better answer because they're fictional characters. Not in every government society would both individuals be punished- sometimes only the actions of the shooter would be punished because as a crime they outweigh the attempt at robbery. |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | So they wouldnt be punished is your answer They're free to kill more people Thats how you get serial killers |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | Just because they are punished doesn't ensure that they won't kill again. And just because there is no governing body does not necessarily mean that there will be implusive robberies and murders. |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | but theres still a chance it would happen people thrive on power if you give them the power to kill with no punishment they can easily take advantage of it |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | Not everybody thrives on power, and not everybody would use this to kill because they knew they would not punished. To not change society because of fear that a minority would abuse its opportunities is unfair to the masses who would not go around killing everyone they see. |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | The masses would suffer "Not everyone thrives on power" It only takes one person to massacre |
| assiralc talc Really Not Okay Age: - Gender: - Posts: 684 | It only takes one person to massacre in a non-anarchist society as well. |
| Austing Banned Age: 33 Gender: Male Posts: 135 | One person who can be caught and dealt with Who's gonna deal with the murderer in anarchy land? No one |
| Me-ninja Joining The Black Parade Age: 32 Gender: Male Posts: 199 | well, if it doesent, mikey told me the rong meaning of anarchy X) |
| Slacker Killjoy Age: 32 Gender: Male Posts: 43 | Amusing Craig, all i said was someone who doesnt beleive in order etc. Which im not sure is 100% right, but hey. |
| bloodredruby69 Banned  Age: 35 Gender: Female Posts: 8293 | Anarchy - The complete lack of government in a society. No accepted governing influences, no laws, no court. Complete and terrible freedom. |
| PunkerThanThou Thinking Happy Thoughts Age: 33 Gender: Female Posts: 596 | bloodredruby69: I'm not an Anarchist, but... That's a HIGHLY blunt, plain, indescriptive way of explaining anarchy- if one heard that, they'd obviously think anarchy is pathetic- Anarchists don't believe in rules, due to the fact that with lack of government, the instinct of humans to revolt vanishes, according to human instinct- and if everyone had what they wanted, there would be no reason to complain. I'm not saying I agree either way, but that's how they view it. |
| bloodredruby69 Banned Age: 35 Gender: Female Posts: 8293 | ^I meant it to be. That is, in a nutshell, what anarchy is. I wanted to be blunt and plain, so that people could interpret it the way they want, and form their own opinions on it. I was offering a description, to the others in here who don't really know what anarchy is. I pulled the first line out of the Oxford Dictionary, to give a no-ruffles definition of anarchy. (I added a "complete" though) The second line was a little clarification, from my POV. |
| ros. Salute You in Your Grave  Age: 36 Gender: - Posts: 2442 | I don't ever think that true anarchy can take place. Someone will always be in charge. Even within rebellions there will always be a leader. |
Options
Go back to top
Go back to top